Free will: “Whether free will exists, what it is and the implications of whether it exists or not are some of the longest-running debates of philosophy and religion.” This is well-stated from Wikipedia. A search on “free will” brings all kinds of philosophical debates, opinions and definitions.
For our purposes, we simply want to examine what Scripture says about our free will to decide for ourselves about anything, but in particular, about deciding on our own to obey God. Can we freely believe that Jesus was the Son of God? Can we exercise free will in choosing to turn from sin and follow Him?
How Scripture answers "Does man have free will?"
Man does have free will to choose a path of good/righteousness1,2,3,5,9,10,15,16,17,18,21. God has put the option to “know him” in front of all mankind2,3,9,11,18. At a certain age everyone is accountable15, and He wishes that everyone respond5,6,9 to the call – like a father does with his children10,14,19. Unfortunately, not all will7,8,16,17,19, and some may even choose it and then fall back12,13,20,21.
It’s actually tough to limit the passages that speak to mankind’s free will. For example, the many passages that teach we will be judged by our works all assume that man has free will to choose. There’s nothing clearer than in God’s direct words1,2,9. To say we don’t have free will makes God a liar1,2,9,15,16,17…it makes Jesus disingenuous3,6,13,19 and any instruction on prayer meaningless11…and it makes the apostles and their message ridiculous4,5,10,14,20,21. Statements like the one in Jeremiah7 are pulled out of context to argue we don’t have free will, but the entire message of the Bible assumes its reader is a free moral agent from beginning1,2, to end6, and all the pages in between3,4,5,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21.
Answer built on scripture-blocks below
1
God establishes a rule in the Garden of Eden that Adam (and later Eve) could choose to obey or disregard.
2
God told Cain he could choose to “do well” and that he “must rule over” sin’s opposing desire.
3
The “Great Commission” from Jesus is premised on the idea that “all nations” (e.g. everyone) has free will to “observe” (or not to observe).
4
Peter instructs the crownd to repent (turn) and be baptized for forgiveness of their sins. He gives them a choice to make of their own free will.
5
If God’s sovereignty is absolute, then God would not need to “desire” that everybody be saved.
6
The invitation is open to anyone that “desires” to “take the water of life”.
7
It doesn’t, since the point here is that the people had fallen so far into sin and were so “accustomed to do evil” that it would be nearly impossible to repent and turn away (e.g. “change his skin”).
!! scripture-block context extra important here !!
God warned them during Isaiah’s day17, and now about 100 years later told Jeremiah that the people of Judah had grown even more sinful than “Faithless Israel” (Jer 3:11) and they were not going to listen to him (Jer 7:27) — but God still sent him to preach repentance to them, and God finally has had enough declaring, “behold, every one of you follows his stubborn, evil will, refusing to listen to me.” (Jer 16:10-12)
8
God, Himself, may allow/permit/provoke someone that is already intent on taking “pleasure in unrighteousness”.
!! scripture-block context extra important here !!
These are in fact people that have “refused to love the truth and so be saved” (vs 10).
9
God set before the people to choose good or evil, and proceeds to instruct how they might accomplish either path. Joshua later repeats this thought and declares his choice before the people18.
10
Our relationship to God is a like children to a Father. A father can be an example, train, enocourage and charge but not force their childrens’ will.
11
If man did not have free will, why would Jesus instruct His disciples to “ask”, “seek” and “knock” to a God already aware of their needs? More specifically, and in the broader context of Jesus’ sermon, why would anyone need to pray?
12
A situation is described where those that have been saved can choose to “crucify once again the Son of God” by their actions.
13
Jesus says that “even the elect” could be led astray by false teachers/false prophets (“false christs” or antichrists).
14
Paul instructs Christian’s to essentially do their part in their salvation, while reminding them that God works in them. Unless Paul is contractdicting himself mid-sentence, he obviously means that God works in them as a support to their own free will (not over-ruling it).
15
God acknowledges a time at which a young person can choose between good and evil.
related to 'Does man have free will?'
lend your own study to the discussion
PUBLIC COMMENT POLICY: While your email is required, it will not be posted publically.
All comments are vetted for potential spam before being published, but will not be restricted otherwise.