Man’s free moral agency suggests that a person is free to make their own choices. Specifically, they are free to make their own decisions about what’s right and wrong. Free moral agency implies or assumes that:

  1. A “free moral agent” understands the difference between right and wrong and has the mental capacity to make a choice.
  2. A person operating under free moral agency is accountable for their choices.
  3. There is no other “agent” or higher power that is forcing the free moral agent to make certain choices. To say that one has “free moral agency” is the same as saying that one has free will – something the Bible clearly teaches.

However, are there conditions that could lead to man’s free moral agency being lost? After all, God is sovereign and desires that all be saved.

How Scripture answers "Can our free moral agency be lost?"

Our free moral agency is progressively compromised through a “searing” of the conscience9 or a “hardness of heart”414 that can occur in one’s life. This is true even for a Christian’s135691214, or from the Old Covenant, one of God’s chosen181315! Often, the Bible talks of this regression as being enslaved to sin23591011. There is a depravity11011 and a craving for the carnal24 that can overcome someone to a point that God will essentially “call it”10, ending one’s chance to repent16.

Like alcohol or drug addiction, the web of sin can become a habit we can’t break6. However, from God’s perspective, it’s never too late to repent111215, as we see in even extreme cases like Manasseh8. Through His word, He encourages that we instead be enslaved to righteousness57, or doing good. This is true freedom27, when one “knows God” and is “known by God”313 – the remedy for being enslaved to sin.

Answer built on scripture-blocks below

Applying Hebrews 12:15-17 to this question...

Esau found himself with “no chance to repent”, even though there was a point at which he wished he could have changed things.

Extra Context for this Application:

The point of the Hebrew writer is clear, given the context of the entire book. It is an urgent plea to Hebrew Christians not to fall away.614

Applying 2 Peter 2:17-19 to this question...

Whatever a person succumbs to or willfully chooses to practice is what will enslave them. Specifically, Peter speaks about a carnal, fleshly depravity that presents as “freedom”, but is only a “slave of corruption.”

Extra Context for this Application:

Peter, like Jude,13 is addressing false teachers among them, but the warning stands for anyone.

Applying Galatians 4:8-9 to this question...

Christians, if they are not careful, can become enslaved to sin or “turn back again”, which is the state they were in before becoming Christians.

Applying Ephesians 4:17-19 to this question...

Paul, just as he warned the Galatian Christians3, is encouraging Christians in Asia Minor not to fall back to being enslaved to sin like Gentiles who “have given themselves up to” a “practice of every kind of impurity”.

Applying Romans 6:15-16 to this question...

Man is a slave to whoever/whatever he allows to be his master. There are two choices: being a slave to sin, leading to [spiritual] death, or being a slave to obedience [the Gospel], leading to righteousness [eternal life].

Applying Hebrews 6:4-6 to this question...

The Hebrews writer describes a state in which a Christian finds it “impossible” to repent.

Extra Context for this Application:

This is essentially the same point the writer makes when using Esau as an example,1 and indeed, the theme of the entire letter.14

Applying Galatians 5:13 to this question...

A Christian’s calling is one of true freedom, if they remain faithful and do not allow the deeds of the flesh to overcome them.

Applying 2 Chronicles 33:12-13 to this question...

They don’t get much worse than Manasseh in the Bible, yet he was able to overcome a lifetime of depravity and still turn to God before it was too late.

Extra Context for this Application:

While Manasseh was able to repent before it was too late, the consequence of his evil leadership over the people of Judah still resulted in the exhaustion of God’s patience and His justice (e.g. being taken captive by Babylon). The people, as free moral agents themselves, were still responsible for their sins.

Applying 1 Timothy 4:1-3 to this question...

One’s conscience can become “seared”, which implies a state of conscience that is dead or at least less aware than it once was.

Applying Romans 1:28 to this question...

God will, at some point, turn people over to their self-determined path of sinful behavior.

Applying Titus 3:3 to this question...

A Christian repents (turns) from their sinful ways and behavior that is described here in the most base and carnal ways.

Applying James 4:8 to this question...

James describes the single-minded focus that’s required for a sinner to turn to God and remain obedient.

Extra Context for this Application:

He has just chastised them for being “adulterous people” and reminds them that they can’t be “friends” with both the world and God (vs 4). It’s one or the other!

Applying Jude 1:11-13 to this question...

Jude excoriates a type of “Christian” that is completely driven by pride (Cain/Korah example) and greed (Balaam example). There is only “utter darkness…forever” (e.g. Hell) awaiting them.

Extra Context for this Application:

We know these are individuals wearing the name Christian, as they have “crept in unnoticed” (vs 4) among the brethren to whom Jude is writing.

Applying Hebrews 3:12-13 to this question...

Christians can become “hardened” by the allure of sin so they should encourage each other every day against this threat.

Applying Joel 2:12-13 to this question...

God is always ready to receive those who truly turn from their wicked ways and humbly repent.8

Leave your comment below…

…and if you’re wondering more about what we’re doing and why, here are some links we hope can help explain it (and maybe even get you excited about contributing):

what do you think?

related to 'Can our free moral agency be lost?'

lend your own study to the discussion

PUBLIC COMMENT POLICY: While your email is required, it will not be posted publically.
All comments are vetted for potential spam before being published, but will not be restricted otherwise.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Treen

My heart has literally been hardened by sin, but how do I know if like Esau if I’m past the point of repentance?